What Works
Thoughtful Concept & Sharp Social Commentary
The film smartly critiques contemporary dating culture, exploring how society increasingly views prospective partners through rigid metrics—wealth, status, and physical attributes. Through her matchmaking business in Manhattan, Lucy (Dakota Johnson) facilitates these transactional unions, and the narrative questions whether love can ever transcend its economic trappings.
Strong Supporting Presence
While the central love triangle sometimes falters, Zoe Winters delivers a standout turn as a disillusioned client, adding emotional texture and thematic weight.
Elegant Cinematography & Production Design
Shabier Kirchner’s visuals juxtapose the pristine world of luxury and tailoring with gritty, lived-in spaces. Costume design and NYC locations contribute to a film that looks polished and layered.
What Falls Short
Emotional Flatness & Lack of Chemistry
Multiple critics observed a notable absence of big emotional stakes. Dakota Johnson’s performance as Lucy is stylish and controlled—but often detached. The romance with Harry (Pedro Pascal) and ex‑boyfriend John (Chris Evans) rarely sparks, rendering the love triangle unconvincing.
Narrative Treadmill Runs Dry
What begins as a sharp deconstruction of romantic tropes devolves into the same beats it aimed to critique. The film eventually reverts to familiar rom‑com formulas, sacrificing emotional nuance for tidy resolution.
Tonally Uneven & Overstuffed
Materialists juggles multiple threads—Lucy’s psyche, satire of the wealthy clients, and her personal triangle—but struggles to unify them. Pacing drags in the second act, and the resolution feels overly neat compared to the premise.
Final Verdict
Materialists is visually sleek, socially observant, and occasionally provocative—but ultimately conflicted in tone. Celine Song presents a Mumbai of ideas—on wealth, romance, and class—but the characters rarely feel alive, and the emotional pulse is missing.
For viewers interested in thoughtful interrogations of modern love, with stylish visuals and an indie edge, Materialists offers occasional insight. But those seeking emotional authenticity, satisfying chemistry, or genuine romantic payoff may find it too cool, too calculated, and ultimately too distant.