Heart Eyes: A Bloody Valentine That Balances Romance and Slasher Thrills

Heart Eyes (2025)

"Heart Eyes," directed by Josh Ruben, is a 2025 film that uniquely blends the romantic comedy and slasher horror genres. The narrative follows Ally (Olivia Holt) and Jay (Mason Gooding), coworkers who, after a chance meeting, find themselves targeted by the Heart Eyes Killer—a masked assailant who preys on couples each Valentine's Day.

Critics have offered mixed to positive reviews. RogerEbert describes the film as "a raving good time," noting its appeal to fans seeking both warmth and horror. Similarly, Decider appreciates its self-aware satire, likening it to the "Scream" series, and recommends it for those seeking light-hearted escapism. However, The Guardian criticizes the film as an "awkward cross" between romantic comedy and horror, suggesting it fails to excel in either genre.

Audience reactions reflect this divide. On Reddit, viewers praise the film's kills, engaging antagonist, and strong performances from Holt and Gooding, though some point out inconsistencies in humor and supporting characters. Rotten Tomatoes features an audience consensus highlighting the film as a "killer mashup" of romance, horror, and comedy, acknowledging a less compelling plot but recognizing its entertainment value.

In summary, "Heart Eyes" offers a novel cinematic experience by merging slasher horror with romantic comedy. While it may not fully satisfy purists of either genre, it provides an entertaining ride for viewers open to a genre-blending narrative.